Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by unsupp0rted 725 days ago
Why can’t we all live in caves and chase our prey across the savannah, all equal, until a broken leg or an infected scratch causes certain death, like nature intended?
2 comments

Might just be me, but I don't think the world would be a better place with a separate caste of immortals controlling the world governments and resources.

Crazy, I know.

It's not crazy, no one thinks that. My question is why do so many people think of and fear this as a plausible scenario, to the point they prefer to rot and die than see progress in that front. Now this is crazy.
Fortunately for everyone involved, this kind of immortality is not invulnerability, and it doesn't quite save the neurons which are slowly dividing cells, only indirectly limiting damage to them.

So you might have doddering 120 year old ancients (potential predicted life extension) with ever more brain damage.

Because if you were a billionaire who had the ability to make people live forever, why would you let the working class have it and not just keep it for you and your immediate family?
If I were a billionaire and wanted to keep it for me and my immediate family... good luck to me.

How would I be able to enforce it? By somehow keeping the costs high? By lobbying?

Nothing would work, because this would be too big for the working class to just sit there and watch, and if lots of people get really pissed, it can turn very ugly, as history has taught.

People will want it and they'll get it, one way or the other.

To others: how are these kind of arguments called? "We probably or may not need X" "Alright you go back to eating bananas in a tree then!"

EDIT: Had forgotten for a second that we can know ask this kind of questions to a computer, "straw man argument".

Reductio ad absurdum. Possibly
Where X = "Starting to rot from the inside out as soon as we hit forty, while simultaneously watching loved ones age badly and becoming decreasingly self-sufficient, at best."

Yeah, who needs "X". I won't even bother with the "the rich" stuff, because, frankly, it's too tired, pathetic, childish and naive.