[akira2501]

> a government-run identity service.

Sponsored and standardized, maybe, /run/ definitely not.

These entities love creating things like "No Fly Lists" I can only imagine what their greedy little hands would do with the authority to strip one of the ability prove their identity.

[krapp]

I wanted to step in and make fun of the Mark of the Beast people and paranoid gun owners who always freak out about things like this but then I considered what half the country would do if they had control over the immutable legal identities of gay and transgendered people, and I realize they might actually have a point.

It's not that a national identity service is a bad idea, it's a good idea and the US should have it, like it should have nationalized healthcare, education, UBI and gun control that's actually effective. It's that the United States government specifically can't be trusted to implement it at any level and in any way that won't lead to undesirables in mass graves. We just can't have nice things here.