Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ddrdrck_ 720 days ago
This sounds terribly odd to me as a European guy. We hear a lot of stories with US cops unloading their guns at people they feel are a menace, only to realize later these people were actually unarmed or just holding a phone. But if someone gives them a middle finger then it is all fine and cops should do nothing but lower their eyes !?

In France to give the middle finger to a policeman or soldier or any other state representant would be considered an offense. People would be fined for this, and not even our leftists would contest that.

5 comments

What law would be broken by this offense?
In America contempt of civil servants is more or less required.
Esprit de corps.

Just kidding- maybe there’s an actual law involved. Either way this sort of example shows how much of an outlier the Bill of Rights is. It’s something worth protecting at all costs.

>>We hear a lot of stories with US cops unloading their guns at people they feel are a menace, only to realize later these people were actually unarmed or just holding a phone.<<

this is why so much desire to shoot the finger.

The Supreme Court said it was considered free speech to give the middle finger. If you yelled profanity at a police man in front of the public you could get a charge like disorderly conduct or something like that.
French leftists would absolutely contest this come on.
Absolutely not. It would ruin all the fun otherwise !
lécheur