Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vlz 721 days ago
I see this as an almost scientific/scholarly exercise in modeling. While the author seems not to start with any intent to "do science" he or she tries to capture a concrete phenomenon abstractly in order to study it more closely, which is arguably at the heart of science or at least some of the sciences.

The post is "almost" scholarly because it does not try to look into what others did before or currently, eg. prior attempts at notation of dance. I would be very surprised if there weren't any. Modeling cultural practices is also somewhat of a hot topic in the so called "Digital humanities" for what that is worth. A quick search for example brought up this article which talks about Dance Studies and attempts at digitization:

https://humanitiesfutures.org/papers/digital-research-in-dan...

Anyways "ornithology for birds" is pretty fitting as this seems to just be anthropology for humans.

2 comments

Yeah, at some point I will try to write out something about all the various dance notations that I've been able to find. My favorite one is from SalsaIsGood.com. Totally incomprehensible to me for the most part, https://web.archive.org/web/20231001115608/https://www.salsa..., however, I really like the diagrams that they made https://web.archive.org/web/20231001115608/https://www.salsa... .

As to whether this all will be useful for learning how to dance, it remains to be seen. I didn't learn how to dance from diagrams and notation, but I also don't think there's that many good diagrams and notations to learn from, so it's hard to say whether it would have been effective or not. My answer at this point is to try and produce stuff that helps people and see whether it's possible or not.

Indeed. Where it goes wrong is the notion it will help people learn how to dance.
I could see stuff like this helping advanced dancers come up with new stuff or perhaps help some instructors.
Indeed invaluable to help dance instructors come up with stuff to sell. Because its so well suited to incomprehensibility e.g. this famous example https://www.tangomovimentoterapia.com/wp-content/uploads/201...