Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by harimau777 735 days ago
Maybe I'm not following, but I'm seeing tons of responses saying that a low fine is alright because this is a local violation. What is the reasoning there? Doesn't the profit go to the corporation as a whole?
1 comments

The penalty must be proportionate to the crime. Otherwise, there's a good chance a higher court will overturn it.

It doesn't matter where the profits go; in this case, management at two warehouses did something wrong, and the fine reflects the scope of the harm done.

If this could be proven to be happening illegally at every warehouse nationwide, then it becomes a larger issue and there will be larger personalities.

It seems to me that it matters where the profit goes because part of "proportionate to the crime" means that the fine is sufficient to discourage the behavior.