Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vidarh 5121 days ago
His summary of the object hierarchy of Ruby is probably more confusing than elucidating to most Ruby beginners, since he doesn't make it very clear that he's dealing with the distinction between instances and classes (which are themselves instances of Class).

From the description it seems like he doesn't quite get the distinction himself, and one of the later examples is broken:

"Array.new.methods - Object.methods" should read "Array.new.methods - Object.new.methods". Otherwise he's in fact subtracting the methods available on an error instance from the methods available on an instance of Class, not the methods available on a generic object..
1 comments
xentronium 5121 days ago
> "Array.new.methods - Object.methods" should read "Array.new.methods - Object.new.methods". Otherwise he's in fact subtracting the methods available on an error instance from the methods available on an instance of Class, not the methods available on a generic object..

You are wrong, classes are objects :)

    1.9.3p194 :084 > Object.new.methods - Object.methods
     => []
link
thenonsequitur 5115 days ago
Actually, the author is inaccurate, comparing apples to oranges. Consider the opposite subtraction than you proposed:

    irb(0main):001:0> Object.methods - Object.new.methods
    => [:allocate, :new, ...]
That means doing "Array.new.methods - Object.methods" is subtracting things that may potentially be methods of an Array instance that should not be subtracted. It just so happens to work in this case because Array has none of those methods. But it doesn't work in the general case.

Consider for example, a "Person" class with a single instance method "name". In this case, "Person.new.methods - Object.methods" will not include "name", because this happens to be a method that applies both to Person instances and the object Object. The correct comparison is what vidarh said, "Array.new.methods - Object.new.methods".

The author's main point, however, was that you can write code like "Array.new.methods" and "Object.methods" at all, and that you can write code to subtract them. And this example shows that nicely.

link