Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by WalterBright 731 days ago
Having lived in Germany for a while, and toured the castles along the Rhein, I was told by the tour guides that toll extraction was their purpose.
3 comments

Tour guides of historical sites are often completely or even willfully wrong about facts like this, but in a sense almost all castles exist to exert control over nearby resources so they're probably right.
It's probably both. Rivers are convenient for transport, which means raiders can also target them since so much valuable stuff is transported that way. A castle is a sensible way (in those times) to put a protective force in place against the raiders. However, the castle and the people protecting river traffic need money, so of course that comes from tolls.

It's no different than any "protection racket" or police force: the money has to come from somewhere to offer protection, so some form of tax is normally used.

You don't really need a whole castle to collect a toll (just a gateway of some kind). You need a castle to protect a village from raiders.