Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pompino 740 days ago
>educational like stuff from Veritasium

People call his videos educational, but really, what is the actual education being imparted? Its superficial, and you will never know how rich the topic actually is, and what the nuances are who the critics are and what they say, etc, etc. I'd put those videos in the entertainment section.

(FWIW I watch those videos too)

2 comments

He is edutainment. Stricktly better than reality TV but don't expect it to be as good as real education.
edutainment is a fair criticism, but it's also a gateway drug. NileRed got me into more detailed chemistry topics, for example.
The recent video about jumping spiders was pretty educational, for example; although I do agree that the informational content has reduced since he started heavily leaning on documentary style videos (the one about dropping pennies from a helicopter being one of the worse ones.)
I think he is good at building a narrative, but I guess I have a different view of what constitutes educational content. Nothing against the guy, I'm glad hes making the videos. Though I wish he would drop his scammy sponsor - betterhelp.