Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sparker72678 740 days ago
300+ days of sun, access to jobs, no snow, nice climate half the year, cheaper than California.
1 comments

Seems pretty logical to me
Guess that is "logic" as in "human logic, what makes me feel good right now and discount all future problems".

That might make sense, doesn't Phoenix also have a pretty high percentage of overweight unhealthy people? Just sitting inside with air conditioning. It fits that method of thinking.

> Guess that is "logic" as in "human logic

I assume the people living in Phoenix are humans, yes. Seems likely they're using the one and only logic available to humans.

Sorry. Forgot the </sarcasm>.

The point was it is not logical, 'human logic' is fallacious. It only appears logical if it justifies what you want.

Seems pretty logical to pursue your own interests, which are inherently human and personal. We don't know the interests of the individuals who choose to live in Phoenix, so we're not in a position to say they're right or wrong, logical or illogical to do so. But, we can guess. It's easy to guess interests which would make the decision to live there completely logical. They may not be your interests or mine, but then again they're not obliged to share your interests or mine. Put another way, if it "justifies" (i.e increases the likelihood of getting) what you want, then it's not that it appears logical. It is logical.
Logic is using facts/premises plus reason. You are describing just doing what you want. Being purely self interested in order to justify your actions.

Technically, being self interested isn't wrong. But it isn't Logic.

Logic

""Logic studies arguments, which consist of a set of premises together with a conclusion. An example is the argument from the premises "it's Sunday" and "if it's Sunday then I don't have to work" to the conclusion "I don't have to work".[1] Premises and conclusions express propositions or claims that can be true or false.""

Self Interest

"First, psychological egoism is a theory about the nature of human motives.

Psychological egoism suggests that all behaviors are motivated by self-interest. In other words, it suggests that every action or behavior or decision of every person is motivated by self interest. It also suggests that every action must be motivated by self interest. The doctrine of selfish motivation is simply a natural law of psychology. Just as it is a natural law of physics that bodies tend to move toward one another in proportion to their masses and at velocities inversely proportionate to their distances from one another, it is a natural law that all motivations are, ultimately, selfish."

Of course, we are getting into definitions of words. And technically, I do agree, people can do what they want, there is no right or wrong. I just don't think it is logical.