[sneak]

You can’t pay YouTube to remove in-video ads that the video creators put in. For that you need SponsorBlock anyway, so might as well use a 3p client that supports blocking both kinds of ads, without giving money to Google to continue building ad surveillance software.

[ok_dad]

I don’t mind ads in the videos for creators I enjoy, it pays their bills. There’s a difference between those and YouTube’s ads which the creators don’t get a big percentage of. I can easily fast forward those ads if I want to, anyways.

How do you expect all this content to be made without any sort of money? You’re basically leeching off the rest of us, in this case, IMO.

I hate ads, but right now that’s the only ticket, or paying for premium. Perhaps that will change, I hope.

[sneak]

I mind all ads. They rob you of your most precious and nonrenewable resource without consent.

Ads are cancer and should be excised at every opportunity. Ad companies should be destroyed. Ad tech workers should be blackballed. Shilling is shameful.

[guyzero]

This entire forum is an advertisement for an investment firm. Many posts are advertisements for startups.

[sneak]

Not really. HN would still be excellent and useful and valuable even if pg and yc ceased to exist.

[ok_dad]

I’ll agree in some capacity that ads are a scourge today, but what’s your alternative? You can’t just burn down the world ave start fresh, there has to be a better way and a plan to transition. Those who would just burn the world down are not mature. This applies to just parts of the world, too, such as “advertising must burn” or “let Y country burn because of X problem” (paraphrasing).

I cannot agree on blackballing workers. That’s just another form of control we shouldn’t exercise. Imagine if someone blackballed you for your career doing whatever you do? They’re just trying to survive and earn a living. Maybe I’ll agree on shaming and calling out execs though.

[sneak]

It’s possible to survive doing things that aren’t shameful and destructive. If we don’t shame and blackball people for their freely taken adult decisions about how to spend their time and direct their effort, what can we shame or blackball people for?

It should be hazardous to your career to engage in certain types of business. Mass murder, advertising, spyware, spam, network abuse (DDoS), or conspiracy to commit same should always make people think twice about hiring you.

[ok_dad]

Hot take, putting advertising employees at the same level as literal murderers.

[jsnell]

The creators get the majority of the ad revenue from YouTube's ads (it's a 55/45 split).

[ok_dad]

55% isn’t big to be when you consider they made the content, though the cost’s for video are probably higher than most things online.

[guyzero]

Do you walk out of a movie once someone drinks a Coke on screen? This seems like a level of ideological devotion that makes doing anything pretty difficult.

[SadTrombone]

Do you have any examples of a movie where someone spends a couple of minutes drinking Coke while talking about how delicious it is and why you should buy it?