Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gertrunde 745 days ago
While I'm not the commenter that you are replying to, I do drive a plug-in hybrid.

I find fuel economy is worse if you don't heavily utilise the electric side, and on-the-road cost is more than a straight petrol engine version of the same car, with less boot storage space as well, as the battery takes up space (and space where a spare tyre now cannot be), although it can make economic sense due to some taxes being less. (e.g. BIK tax rate of ~8-10% vs ~25-30%).

You'll only really get good fuel economy if you are plugging it in to charge every night, and doing a correspondingly suitable amount of daily miles.

And if you're plugging the car in overnight every night... you might as well just get a full BEV anyway.

The whole plug-in hybrid thing just feels like a tax dodge (either because it take advantage of perverse incentives, or works around low emission schemes), or a halfway house for people who aren't yet ready to make the jump to a BEV.

For me, even driving one (for the aforementioned financial considerations), I feel the reasons to buy/drive a plug in hybrid don't really make sense from any other point-of-view, and at this stage my next car is most likely to be a BEV.

2 comments

That doesn't make much sense. Hybrids literally have much better MPG figures and that takes into account that you can't run off battery to cheat these numbers.

Regenerative breaking is a huge MPG win and you can't do that without being Hybrid.

I entirely agree with you, on paper they should have better MPG.

But I don't find those figures reflected in my actual on the road experience.

Edit: That may say something about my driving style though! ;)

Edit2: The situation may be different for PHEV vs normal hybrid (more battery weight for PHEV), and may change with quality of hybrid power management implementation.

What vehicle/year/model?
2021 Seat Leon

(Edit: Not a bad car, it's fine, just less than expected in a few areas, namely fuel economy and boot space)