[MikeSchurman]

I love this. Probably because I've been thinking of similar ideas for what seems like the last decade, I just have coders block when it comes to actually implementing it. Seeing it (well something like it) actually implemented makes me happy.

My use-case would be a "real-time" debug tool of sorts, that would allow the viewing of trees as they have, but also the modification of them, and the values at the nodes (think the hierarchy+inspector of unity3d, but a remote tool).

Anyway this post is food for thought and I'm going to read more about how it was done. I like the API they've created for sending views, really interesting.

[wormius]

I think this is possibly related to something I was thinking about when dealing with graph traversal in Python, wanting a debug tool that let me snapshot each step but then diff the watched variables. Being able to move back and forth to see the state change, and the connections so I could determine what was influencing the state. This was because no matter how hard I tried, I kept running into variables that I was watching that appeared to be the same reference, have different values (so I know I was referring to something wrong, but could not for the life of me figure it out, and though if I only had a way to step/trace and do this visually like an AST that highlights changed values and you could see back to its root where it's actually being modified visually)

I found out there's a thing called "deterministic debugging" (and the biggest known example afaict is rr: https://rr-project.org/

Apparently MS has a time-travel debugger... I pictured the AST being populated and repopulated via the steps, and the ability to diff changes over time.

Here's a wiki on various systems, though most of these seem to be typical text based "trace" options.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_travel_debugging (I hazard that this may be similar to some of the power of Common Lisps REPL, but could be wrong)

I found a professor at one point doing some research and he seemed to have given up without more funding. I thought I had it bookmarked, but am unable to find it right now. If I can remember (ha) I'll see if I can find it tomorrow. He had the most interesting approach that seemed closest to what I think you (and possibly I) are thinking, with propagation through the tree (I don't think I was picturing editing the graph directly per se - but that would be a cool idea).

Have you looked into LightTable or Brett Victor's work at all? http://lighttable.com/ (somewhat tangentially related, I think?)

Sorry this is so scattered I need to hit the hay LOL.

[MikeSchurman]

Yes, I'm a big fan of Bret Victor's work. I share his Inventing on Principle talk on a near yearly basis.

I've seen light table years ago and thought it looked really neat, but I haven't looked into it much as it wasn't directly applicable to my environments. But, probably worth a look for ideas.

On the topic of time-travel debugging, have you seen the demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72y2EC5fkcE (Tomorrow Corporation Tech Demo) Very impressive, worth a watch.

[homedirectory]

Thank you for sharing this demo. Amazing stuff! Inspired me to start working on improvements to the development environment of my team.

[anonzzzies]

Ah thanks, I was trying to remember Lighttable; there must be emacs plugins for CL for that I guess? As some type of more addition to the REPL functionality; having it more automated?

[wormius]

Oh Sorry I don't know if there's more functionality - didn't mean to imply something like LightTable exists for it, but for some reason I thought it allowed you to step back and forward in the execution to watch things (still based in text, etc... I have SBCL on my system but never really played with it beyond "hello world" so have never actually used the full power of the REPL).

AFAIK it doesn't have any sort of extension like this though. But maybe someone with more CL experience can advise! Hopefully someone has a better idea for you :)

I see the stuff in the parent post but not sure exactly what it can do vs what I envision or you may be picturing...

[wormius]

Maybe this? https://undo.io/resources/step-backwards-time-your-program-v...

[jpmonettas]

Have you seen http://www.flow-storm.org/. It does time travel debugging for Clojure and has a bunch of features.

[refset]

FlowStorm really looks like it delivers on "execution is data", per https://www.scattered-thoughts.net/writing/the-shape-of-data

[wormius]

Interesting I'll have to look at that.

[slifin]

Clojure has a practical time travel debugger

I use it a lot at work it's fun

[worthless-trash]

I have something written which does 'real time graphing' of data, its so stupid.

I'd much prefer to use more mature code, but I haven't seen anything similar.

[MikeSchurman]

Same! I did this in unity3d, but also want to add this to my remote tool. Where can I find the motivation? :)

This is also a very handy idea...