Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by frutiger 753 days ago
Not taking a side in this debate, but what is ownership? As far as I can tell it is an invented concept and has no objective truth, only a "truth that we all agree on".
4 comments

Would you philosophize about ownership if someone stole your laptop or phone?

Side tangent: there is an interesting Vox story about a Greenland meteorite. It illustrates the real human cost of these expeditions that filled museums. Therefore I find it hard to disentangle “ownership” from “violence”. In this story, the change of ownership is a violent and traumatic event.

https://youtu.be/yvdtWfHpCR4

If someone held a gun to your head and stole your laptop or phone, yes, I'm sure the OP won't try to claim they own the laptop anymore and go to the owners house asking for it back.

Stealing through force is very different to stealing through deception alone. History is made by the first, and ruined by the last.

That's easy, man!

Ownership is when you buy a movie and then can watch it as many times as you want... until the streaming service goes out of business.

Oh, sorry, I meant "book" and "read".

No, sorry, wrong again... geez...

I like the word "possession" for this. Either actual possession, when you physically control and can use something, and constructive possesion, where you might not have physical contact with something but still control it.

Ownership is when you convince the right people that you should possess something.

Come on, you know exactly what he means.
Given the debate about the ethics of how the museum sourced its artifacts, I think this is a prime example of ownership being complicated.
Its quite simple, actually. The complication only comes from the mental gymnastics required for legitimising how a museum sources its artifacts.