Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vorakl 758 days ago
This is an interesting one. What was the version of tar? Was it gnu tar? I wonder, how did you create that archive?

I'm asking this because I was trying to reproduce the same situation and everything seems to be working fine:

  $ tar -C /tmp/root3 -cvf test.tar .
  ./
  ./.config/
  ./.config/test
  ./.local/
  ./var/
  ./var/db/
  ./var/db/xbps/
or even like this

  $ tar -cvf test2.tar root3/
  root3/
  root3/.config/
  root3/.config/test
  root3/.local/
  root3/var/
  root3/var/db/
  root3/var/db/xbps/
No special options were needed. But, if I do it this way, then, there are definitely missing all dot directories:

  $ tar -cvf test2.tar root3/*
  root3/usr/
  root3/usr/bin/
  root3/usr/bin/xbps-uunshare
But this problem is not a tar's problem. That's only because "*" mask doesn't match dot files:

  $ echo root3/*
  root3/usr root3/var
For that purpose, you need to clearly add a dot:

  $ echo root3/.*
  root3/.config root3/.local
Thus, the solution might be

  $ tar -cvf test2.tar root3/.* root3/*
  root3/.config/
  root3/.config/test
  root3/.local/
  root3/usr/
  root3/usr/bin/
But, I'd rather stick to "-C dir/" option instead of relying on "*" mask in this case.
1 comments
doublerabbit 758 days ago 

   tar -cvf mytar.tar /home/myuser/*
Was definitely the syntax I ran. I'm on FreeBSD so just tar.
link
vorakl 758 days ago
Then, this explains why. BTW, this is an expected Shell behavior, specified in the POSIX standard:

  If a filename begins with a <period> ( '.' ), the <period> shall be explicitly
  matched by using a <period> as the first character of the pattern or immediately
  following a <slash> character. The leading <period> shall not be matched by:
   * The <asterisk> or <question-mark> special characters
https://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/utilities/V...

Interesting fact about the FreeBSD tar's origins:

  GNU tar was included as the standard system tar in
  FreeBSD beginning with FreeBSD 1.0.
  This is a complete re-implementation based
  on the libarchive(3) library. It was first released with
  FreeBSD 5.4 in May, 2005.
https://man.freebsd.org/cgi/man.cgi?query=tar

My personal journey with FreeBSD began with version 5.3 (the first stable release on the 5th branch) in November 2004. I was completely unaware of such a significant tar change, and apparently I didn't care at the time. However, the entire 5th branch has been so revolutionary compared to the 4th branch that this change is just a drop in the bucket ;)

link