Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by HL33tibCe7 759 days ago
> or they are seeking to punish Gazans in general for the actions of a few terrorists on October 7th, eye-for-an-eye style

High-ranking Israeli officials have openly stated this at the start of the war and throughout.

2 comments

Israel’s minister of national security has explicitly said he wants to ethnically cleanse Gaza.

https://x.com/NTarnopolsky/status/1792891809498022385

He has also:

* Been denied entry to the IDF/excused from mandatory conscription due to his extremist views

* Been convicted (in an Israeli court) of supporting a terrorist organization.

* Made a legal career out of defending alledged Jewish terrorists in Israeli courts.

* Arguably contributed to the assassination Yitzhak Rabin and the collapse of the Oslo accords.

Do you speak hebrew? I don't see subtitles to that video, where do you get that?
Here’s a synopsis reported by the Times of Israel

https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/ben-gvir-says-h...

The subtitled video doesn't say anything about ethnic cleansing, the minister says he would like to see those who were exiled from Gaza in 2005 returned and allow Jews to live there again. He makes no mention of displacing the current population.
The subtitled video doesn't say anything about ethnic cleansing

But of course it does exactly that, via the intentionally deceptive euphemism "voluntary emigration".

What? Literally in the first paragraph:

> Far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir says he would be “very happy to live in Gaza” following the war, musing that a mass exodus of Palestinians could create room for a significant influx of Israeli settlers.

I don't know what else to call a "exodus of Palestinians" to "create room". This is pretty much the textbook definition of than ethnic cleansing. And "voluntary emigration"? Right. To where? And after 80 years of fighting over all of this it's suddenly going to be all that "voluntary". Yeah...

This is not some rando we can perhaps interpret in good faith; this is a man who for years had the portrait of terrorist Baruch Goldstein in his office and has repentantly praised him. This, combined with many other things he has said and done over the last 15 years or so means it's pretty clear what he's saying: getting rid of the Untermensch to make lebensraum for the Übermenschen.

Hamas is a complex entity, the ruling party of Gaza as well as a militant terrorist arm. The population of Gaza is around two million people, all of Hamas is maybe 50,000 people, terrorist arm is some subset of that, and the people who actually participated in the Oct 7 atrocities are maybe a few thousand counting all support personnel. I think that easily qualifies as a few people compared to two million.