Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lethologica 750 days ago
In the same way that photoshop meant that people didn’t have to learn how different brushes and mediums work on different surfaces?

People have been worrying about this since the time Socrates thought that books would make people dumb because they wouldn’t need to memorise anything.

I’m an artist and I’m excited to see how people learn to use these new tools in creative ways.

1 comments

It really isn't the same. Photoshop is

a) not a drawing app

b) an expensive prosumer tool with a UI that rivals airplane instrument panels in terms of density. Most kids would be turned off by that as soon as they open it.

MS Paint OTOH is free and has been built into Windows for decades, so it's often the first drawing app kids use (may be different now because of mobile apps). Either way, the 'loss-of-skills' concern here is correlated with the dumbing-down of computing in general, from Gen Z's confusion about file managers and directory structures, to using Grammarly and ChatGPT to write papers.

When I was growing up, my parents would say "You won't always have a calculator in your pocket". Well, they were wrong, but that doesn't mean I don't still benefit from being able to do math in my head for general life stuff (and back of the napkin calculations at work).