Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by distances 755 days ago
I totally agree that the fair failed badly at validating the submissions.

> The child is nothing to be blamed for, it is a 100% problem of the organizers.

This is what I disagree with. A 17 year old is not an innocent child that mustn't be blamed. At this age (and already earlier too) there has to be real consequences for plagiarism, proportionate to the case.

Plagiarize coursework? Fail the course. Cheat in final exams? Fail the exams and retake the year. And so on.

1 comments

So let him fail the science fair and probably be banned from entering this science fair and probably other ones if they're federated.

If that's not his first participation then the previous ones should also be reevaluated.

But that doesn't have much point since he's growing out of them already. And I don't think it's fair to pursue him further (other than existing bad publicity) since people do stupid things all the time and the idea of limited liability exists for a reason.