Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by marcodiego 760 days ago
"Sharing classified documents...". That's a very complicated issue. If those documents put (innocent) people and national safety in risk he is in a very hard to defend position.
5 comments

Here's the actual judgment, including the particulars of the offence.

https://www.courts.act.gov.au/supreme/judgments/r-v-mcbride-...

Hmmmm which innocent people and whose national safety?

The way I recall leaks from the US in Iraq and Afghanistan, the leaks typically depicted the U.S. killing or torturing innocent people. Sure, it's plausible they might have made some soldiers less safe.

But innocence is not so cut and dry. You can't only look from one perspective and see the whole picture.

However, if these documents' contents put the nation in shame then it's going to stick regardless of the verdict.
Why do you speculate? The case has been all over the news for months
I mean, he presumably wasn’t sharing them with the enemy. National security is not at risk from the action of sharing documents an sich.