Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Terr_ 768 days ago
If you ever find yourself stranded back in time at that spot, skip over the fancy clocks and invent a radio transmitter that can send out a powerful pulse for "it's noon in $city" once a day.

Then sailing ships can manage with simple receiver plus clock just good enough to measure 12 hours. The time delta between receiving the land-broadcast and their own observed noon will tell them their relative longitude.

Since you aren't trying to encode any other information in this pulse, that makes the job a lot easier than if you were trying to make a wireless telegraph.

If you want to restrict who can benefit (e.g. to support a particular military that happened to recognize your time-traveler genius) plan random offsets for when you will be triggering it, and give authorized users a copy of the offsets.

1 comments

How difficult is it to determine local noon at sea? I assume that on a rocking ship, it's probably not a trivial task...
IANAMariner, but I'm assuming the sextant would already be invented, since it would also be important for determining latitudes.

The goal is to figure out when the sun is as-close-as-possible to the reference vector "straight up". On land, we might determine that vector using gravity and a plumb-bob, which is indeed going to be a lot harder on a rolling ship.

However way out at sea, a new option exists: The horizon is no longer an arbitrary mishmash of mountains and hills, but instead self-leveling water in every direction [0], meaning you can safely assume "straight up" is 90 degrees [1] from all points on the horizon.

So you'd measure the angle between the sun and the nearest horizon, and then noon would be when that angle hits its minimum.

[0] Tides exist, but I assume they aren't likely to cause one direction to be significantly higher than the other.

[1] Unless you're measuring from very high up above sea-level, but if the civilization can make ships that big then you probably don't need much navigational help.

> and then noon would be when that angle hits its minimum.

*Maximum, but yannowhatimean.