Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 0xB31B1B 763 days ago
"My kids, for instance, love to hammer Alexa with random questions. They would spend a huge amount of time using a better interface, esp. with quick feedback, that provided even deeper insight and responses to them."

Great, using GPT-4 the kids will be getting a lot of hallucinated facts returned to them. There are good use cases for tranformer currently but they're not at the "impact company earnings or country GDP" stage currently, which is the promise that the whole industry has raised/spent 100+B dollars on. Facebook alone is spending 40B on AI. I believe in the AI future, but the only thing that matters for now is that the models improve.
2 comments
practice9 763 days ago
I always double-check even the most obscure facts returned by GPT-4 and have yet to see a hallucination (as opposed to Claude Opus that sometimes made up historical facts). I doubt stuff interesting to kids would be so out of the data distribution to return a fake answer.

Compared to YouTube and Google SEO trash, or Google Home / Alexa (which do search + wiki retrieval), at the moment GPT-4 and Claude are unironically safer for kids: no algorithmic manipulation, no ads, no affiliated trash blogs, and so on. Bonus is that it can explain on the level of complexity the child will understand for their age

link
htrp 763 days ago
Yet.... https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05905
link
dvaun 763 days ago
My kids get erroneous responses from Alexa. This happens all the time. The built-in web search doesn't provide correct answers, or is confusing outright. That's when they come to me or their Mom and we provide a better answer.

I still see this as a cool application. Anything that provides easier access to knowledge and improved learning is a boon.

I'd rather worry about the potential economic impact than worry about possible hallucinations from fun questions like "how big is the sun?" or "what is the best videogame in the world?", etc.

There's a ton you can do here, IMO.

Take a look at mathacademy.com, for instance. Now slap a voice interface on it, provide an ability for kids/participants to ask questions back and forth, etc. Boom: you've got a math tutor that guides you based on your current ability.

What if we could get to the same style of learning for languages? For instance, I'd love to work on Spanish. It'd be far more accessible if I could launch a web browser and chat through my mic in short spurts, rather than crack open Anki and go through flash cards, or wait on a Discord server for others to participate in immersive conversation.

Tons of cool applications here, all learning-focused.

link
cruffle_duffle 763 days ago
People should be more worried about how much this will be exploited by scammers. This thing is miles ahead of the crap fraudsters use to scam MeeMaw out of her life savings.
link