Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by moreati 5127 days ago
I wonder if false positives will take off e.g. personal attack alarms that make a sound like gun fire
2 comments

My dad was using a powder-actuated concrete nail gun for some remodeling not long ago. It used .22 loads to drive nails. The sound it made was eerily identical to the real thing.
The system will have to distinguish real firearms from other powder-actuated hardware. Otherwise it's going to become useless anywhere near a construction site.

But what if you shoot a person with a nail gun?

> But what if you shoot a person with a nail gun?

What if you stab a person with a knife?

It's off-topic. It was designed and built to detect gunshots from real guns.

I think the best way to distinguish between firearms and nail guns would be with a man in the loop listening to the sounds (which they appear to have). Construction doesn't sound like a firefight.
Wouldn't it make more sense to make the alarm send out a standardised frequency a la DTMF tones?