[uniqueuid]

True, we seem to have a pretty similar perspective after all.

My concern is an ecological one within science, and your argument addresses the frontier of scientific methods.

I am sure both are compatible. One interesting question is what instruments are suitable to reduce negative externalities from bad actors. Pre-registration works, but is limited to few fields where the stakes are high. We will probably similarly see a staggered approach with more restrictive methods in some fields and less restrictive ones in others.

That said, there remain many problems to think about: E.g. what happens to meta-analyses if the majority of findings comes from the same mechanism? Will humans be able to resist the pull of easy AI suggestions and instead think hard where they should? Are there sensible mechanisms for enforcing transparency? Will these trends bring us back to a world in which trust was only based on prestige of known names?

Interesting times, certainly.