Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mewpmewp2 768 days ago
I find your reasoning quite odd. It either must be 0 effect or actively harmful to not justify a $10/cost. How much do you value an hour of your time? Because even 1 percent productivity gain would be worth more than $10 a month for me.
2 comments

They explained decently how it was harmful. Cleaning up after it regularly broke things, when given a chance.

To be blunt, it's perfectly reasonable. They didn't even get that proclaimed "one percent!"

How does one even meaningfully measure this? No matter.

In their case, instead of saving time or effort, it was adding. It was a removable cost.

If one really wants to dwell, there's game theory. Could it be made to be effective? Probably. Is it worth it? Don't know.

They told us 'no', we should listen for their situation.

At risk of splitting hairs, I need more than one percent. This isn't a vacuum, I'm not a spherical cow, etc.

Point being: wanting both my money and attention has a high bar of admission. Learning a thing has a cost, becoming dependent, and so on.

I'm well into rambling now, feel free to tune out. I'm not sacrificing autonomy for a pittance. I was fine before I knew about $OFFERING. Truth in advertising is idealistic, at best.

But saying it wasn't worth the $10 contradicts a bit with net negative harm. The way they worded it, made it sound like while there was harm, there was some sort of benefit, but it just wasn't worth specifically $10.
I guess I see it like how I see any autofill, like the one above my keyboard on my phone right now. When I first got a smartphone and saw it, I was thrilled and messed around with it. I would play with it and see how things would go if I just spammed it to see how sentences turn out. Eventually I just cut it out even if it might save me time. I don't care about it anymore, and life isn't just about reaching the end of a sentence as quickly as possible.

However in the case of AI, I am not sure it helps me code any faster. I have to do tons of code cleanup when it messes something up and I "forgot" the logic of how the application was working because I let AI take the reins.