Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by subwindow 5132 days ago
I wrote software for medical devices for 3 years. Saying 'just use NTP' is all well and good, except that getting Internet access inside of a hospital is usually impossible. So of course we offered a configurable setting so that they could use an internal or firewall-allowed server. I think one hospital took advantage of that setting. Everybody else was just wrong.
4 comments

NTP settings can be distributed by DHCP, which in a managed networked environment should be reasonably trustable.

Unfortunately Windows ignores this, and also sets the system clock to a timezone-specific time, not UTC as nearly all other OS's do.

Configuring every single device to use NTP is a hassle. Do medical devices on an intranet use DHCP? DHCP is capable of handing out NTP server addresses, although I don't think it's very common. Another hacky option would be to override "pool.ntp.org" on the intranet's DNS server so it points to an internal server.
Well, if it could be regulated, you could require that the hospital put the NTP server or equivalent on IP over power line.
Not sure how old your experience is, but there's increasingly less friction here.