Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by marginalia_nu 770 days ago
There's probably several sides to this.

On the one hand, we're talking about experiences that we previously would have kept to ourselves, in a way that is probably healthy.

On the other hand, we tend to medicalize life experiences in a way that may not be helpful.

If you for example view every unpleasant experience you have as psychological trauma that is expected to leave an indelible scar on your soul, that's an expectation that may do more harm than good. Especially combined with the notion that people exist that never have any of these negative experiences ever, that walk through life unblemished, living it as it should have been had that one fateful event never happened.

You can absolutely get messed up by traumatic events and this is a real thing, but if we set the expectation that this is always the case, we may plant the suggestion that has even those that would have otherwise walked it off marked for life.

I've also noticed a trend where people tend to sort of frame themselves in terms of their diagnoses (like ADD and Autism/Asperger), almost like a Jungian archetype, as though these diagnoses are causes of behaviors and not descriptions of them.

Although most of these problems likely stem from pop-culture psychology. It's probably something that comes from media portrayals of mental illness much more than it does from the medical professions.

1 comments

Social contagion fueled by a society that only values individuals by their position in an unspoken, disgusting caste system of perceived oppression.