Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dylan604 774 days ago
This seems like one of those better to ask for forgiveness than permission issues getting resolved. SO knew their value was already taken for free. They also know there is absolutely nothing they can do since the models have already been trained. The only thing left to do to salvage any value was to make a press release blessing the theft so they don't look silly going forward.
1 comments
beeboobaa3 774 days ago
Nothing has been resolved. OpenAI still infringed on copyright and should still be punished for this.

They broke the law on a grand scale, used this to make shitloads of money, and are now trying to use that money to pay off anyone that might give them trouble.

Classic mob mentality.

link
dylan604 774 days ago
SO has to make a decision of how much can they prove in court. If they can prove it, what kind of damages might they be awarded, and if any rewards would cover the the expense of bringing the case forward. If any of those questions are a "no", then you have to try to save face some how. This is that face saving move. So to me, it sounds like they decided "no" was an answer somewhere in the decision tree.

When you steal, steal big. You go to jail for stealing someone's things, but if you steal everyone's things, then it's just too much for people to handle and they'd rather the whole thing just goes away really. (maybe I've read too much Douglas Adams)

link
beeboobaa3 774 days ago
> When you steal, steal big. You go to jail for stealing someone's things, but if you steal everyone's things, then it's just too much for people to handle and they'd rather the whole thing just goes away really. (maybe I've read too much Douglas Adams)

You're correct that this is how it works. It's just really sad, and shouldn't be.

People like Aaron Swartz got bullied into suicide, yet OpenAI is getting white glove treatment.

link
artninja1988 774 days ago
>infringed on copyright

It still isn't clear if training on copyrighted data is infringement or not. Please stop spreading misinformation

link
beeboobaa3 774 days ago
It isn't clear whether you're someone worth talking to or just an OpenAI troll.
link