[LegionMammal978]

At least on x86, there's no real point in detecting truncation before upcasting, since expanding multiplication yields both the high and low halves in a single instruction. At best, you'd be adding branches that the processor can insert just as well itself. (Unless we're talking about things like 128x128-bit multiplication, which would be a different story; it would likely depend on your expected input distribution.)

As for returning an overflow bit, Rust has had this since forever with its overflowing_OP() methods, and C23 has recently added an <stdckdint.h> header with a bunch of ckd_OP() macros that return an overflow bit.