Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by BobaFloutist 783 days ago
>I can't really blame a for-profit corporation for using the laws as they are written.

It's funny how whenever a corporation behaves hostilely toward its community, or its customers, or its competitors the rallying cry is "Well it's for profit, they might as well do whatever is mathematically correct", but whenever people turn around and try to make the behavior mathematically incorrect by, say, regulating the corporation or refusing to do business with them or protesting and blocking the factory site they're all of a sudden being unfair and disrupting legitimate business operations.
1 comments
tombert 783 days ago
I can't speak for other people but I'm 100% onboard with increasing regulations so that it's illegal and/or too expensive for corporations to do unethical things. I'm also alright with people refusing to do business with companies that they feel operate unethically. I'm onboard with protesting and potentially blocking the sites as well.

I'm just saying that a corporation is sort of like the frog/scorpion story; it's their nature to maximize profit in any way they can, and at some point you can't even really blame them. It's up to governments and customers to make bad practices illegal or impractical.

link
BobaFloutist 783 days ago
I still fully blame them. There're plenty of corporations that make an effort to embed themselves in their communities as stakeholders and engage the public. It's entirely possible to run a successful business without fucking over your workers, your customers, or your community.

I think we give way too much of a free pass to the actual people making the actual decisions to fuck people over. I think if we started yelling at them and ostracizing them more instead of just shrugging and saying it's the nature of the game, there'd be a lot less misbehavior going around.

link
tombert 783 days ago
Sure, I have no issue with thinking that the people in charge of companies are assholes. I don't have much nice stuff to say about pretty much any CEO of big tech companies (and most other companies either). From a social level it's totally fine to dislike them. I also think it's fine to yell at them or ostracize them. I'm not going to stop you if you treat Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos or Rupert Murdoch badly on Twitter or something.

I'm just saying that we kind of have to expect this stuff. If there is a loophole, I think we have to assume that someone eventually finding it and exploit it. I'm not saying that every corporation is always going to do it, just that some definitely will. It's up to lawmakers and voters to ensure that the loopholes are closed.

link