Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 65 779 days ago
Call me a Luddite but I don't want more and more technology. I don't want AI. I want to build my own house, grow my own food, make my own shoes.

We've had lots and lots of economic growth... but at what cost?

3 comments

It's not possible to live a life of modern conveniences, cost and time savings without technology and specialisation.

Youtubers who grow their own farm can only do it because it's their full time job. Or all their time is spent on the farm. Growing food is not easy, and would cost way more home grown.

Not something to romanticise. Nor would going out to the woods help, the carbon footprint would be so much higher than being able to have a expensive house with mega efficient everything.

Yeah, I thought I'd like & appreciate AI. But of course it's been perverted and twisted by the bigcorps to the point it's just a useless gimmick for making rich people even more money, while making the life of normies much worse.

Can't wait to never be able to contact a company again because they want me to talk to their ai shitbot that's designed to trick me into going away and not bothering them.

>I don't want AI.

Don't use it.

>I want to build my own house, grow my own food, make my own shoes.

AI is not stopping you from doing these things.

I'm not saying this as a direct 1:1 link between the two. I'm using AI as an example for advancing technology. And by the way, advanced technology like smartphones and social media and the internet are all basically required for modern life. As much as I'd like to enjoy living on a farm in the middle of no where, not many other people would enjoy that either and therefore I'd be (mostly) alone, defeating the entire purpose of a neo-Luddite lifestyle - to get back to being a human in an increasingly alienated world.
There are many groups in the US that live with very little use of advanced technology, but very few people have joined them from outside, the vast majority leave after experiencing the lifestyle for some time, modern conveniences are hard to leave behind. It's easy to judge others for not wanting to live your "neo-Luddite lifestyle", I believe they are less delusional than you.
You seem a little aggressive here. Trying to go to a more primitive lifestyle now, in 2024, is largely futile. If it were, say, 500 years ago or 2000 years ago, "modern" life back then would have been simpler - and participating in society would involve many of the agrarian practices I've mentioned. With it comes horrible things like serfdom and slavery, too. Modern life has its benefits as well.

And I have met a lot of Amish people, they seem pretty content. They build furniture and barns. Drive horse carriages.

This is just my vision of an "ideal" life and more importantly an ideal _society_ - it's not as though I'm actively trying to move out to the woods or become Amish.

I just wish for less endless technological advancement and more self-sufficiency.