Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dewey 780 days ago
If you criticize something where you have no context, were not part of the discussions and aware of the trade offs that were made it comes across a bit arrogant to say they should “obviously” “just” do something else.

There’s other ways to suggest an alternative solution.

1 comments

Maybe it comes off that way a bit, but I can only go off what's in the blog post where they begin by calling the existing solution bloated in order to justify their new solution without ever mentioning that the debug table contains much more than just function names and line number mappings.

I do think it should be obvious that displaying text directly in the console is better than relying on a web service to display that same text.

OBVIOUSLY you haven't read the blog post since it is about a crash REPORTER: making it easy for users to REPORT crashes to the maintainers with all of the relevant info. Offering a link with a pre-filled form is OBVIOUSLY easier than making the user copy-paste console text into a browser.