Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by beAbU 785 days ago
No snark intended below:

I'm genuinely curious what the difference is according to you.

From where I'm standing I sometimes struggle to see the difference between my government and a mafia. They behave in uncanny similar ways.

2 comments

It is not impossible for a government to act as a mafia (see Russia). But I believe it's impossible for a mafia to be a functional government, they are just built on different grounds.

For me a functional government has the wellbeing of its citizens as a mission. There might be different opinions on how that would look like (hence democracy) but the idea is that; once the government is unchangeable and only cares about maximising the profits of its cadre then it starts becoming more and more like a mafia, just a legalised one.

>> It is not impossible for a government to act as a mafia (see Russia)

I'm reading the Black Book of Communism and that's my exact impression of the Bolsheviks.

From Goodfellas: "If we wanted something we just took it. If anyone complained twice they got hit so bad, believe me, they never complained again".

That was the Bolsheviks circa 1920.

At the scale seen in Palermo (though not only Palermo, by any means) it is effectively a government (and this point is an element of the article), but without a constitution (unless you count "submit to violence" as one) and sustained economically by extortion, corruption, and drug- and human-trafficking.

Lest this seems smug, let me say that, with SCOTUS struggling to find anything wrong in the events of January 6 2021, I am not feeling at all smug.

> with SCOTUS struggling to find anything wrong in the events of January 6 2021

Might want to work on your reading comprehension there.