[talldayo]

They've existed for almost 4 decades now under a market labelled "MPCs and MIDI controllers". To name a few common alternatives, you have the Digitakt and Octatrack, a cheap TASCAM and a laptop, a 4-track cassette recorder, the Akai grooveboxes, the Electribe series, the recent Novation Circuit line... the list goes on. People have been making beats on battery-power long before the iPhone and Garageband, if that's news to anyone.

> I don't even know HOW I would do that without TE gear, $50k worth of Eurorack?

A quad-core laptop running Reason and VCV Rack would do just as well, but I won't spoil your hardware fun. Who can deny how sweet TE's analog DCO sounds?

[neom]

Right, anyway. Can you spec for spec find me alternatives for the TE gear I mentioned? Same form function, similar software, interoperable within its ecosystem. Just name the TE model and then the brand and model alternative that is basically the same, and then how they work together in terms of their sync clocks.

For example:

OP-Z, you could buy X device, it has all the same features, is about the same price, same size, battery etc.

Very curious to check out your suggestions!

[talldayo]

OP-Z: iPhone or iPad, it has all the same features, is about the same price, same size as you would have carried, same battery, whatever

OP-1: Literally just about anything. It is a 4 channel digital recorder. You have an iPhone with USB-class compliant audio, you can do multichannel recording. Use a guitar, some iOS plugins and a $40 DAC. If you're going to complain about buttons, go blow your cash on a midi controller (it will still come up cheaper than ANY OF THE OP-1 MODELS!)

Pocket Operator: God, please grant me reprieve from finite suffering. There is no hope for humanity if we are looking for "alternatives" to grooveboxes with kilobyte-sized memory. What do I say? Fairlight CMI? Do I send a picture of the Mellotron as a joke? The Ti-84 graphing calculator? Heaven forbid... the Akai Rhythm Wolf. Is there a future for us yet if iPad children would rather pay college-tuition prices for Fischer-Price hardware that can do what their iPad does already?

You'll never please everyone, which is why snake oil still finds customers in the 21st century.

[silentsanctuary]

You have an audience eager for genuine alternative recommendations - why not use it? Instead you've spent a lot of words and mock despair not providing any answer to GP, when we want to hear what technologies you would suggest instead.

You can't take someone's OP-Z out of their hands and replace it with an iPhone and expect them to be able to continue, unless you're also recommending a specific iPhone DAW/sequencer with comparable functionality and usability? People would be very keen to hear which ones you like!

And replacing a Pocket Operator's functionality with a Ti-84? If the future of hope for humanity depends on everyone seeing that a Ti-84 is an obviously fully capable substitute for a Pocket Operator, should I be worried that I don't see it (it doesn't even have the right ports, for one thing)?

You seem to have a lot of conviction in your position, we'd love to see some of the substance behind it!

[kasrkin623]

Not OP and this is a week old thread, but I own multiple OP-Zs, OP-1f, and PO-133. Been using OP-Z since release. Big fan of their gear but not the build quality.

Here is what possibly could work:

OP-1f: a tough one to replace but possibly an iPhone + AUM app for multitrack recording and file management + any of the daws such as garageband for recording

Synths / drums apps - probably any, also Koala sampler is pretty solid.

Effects and sequencers would be hard to replicate though, might need an iPad for that (and there you can just use a Samplr app for instance)

Will need a separate audio interface and maybe a microphone though.

OP-Z: an even tougher task, sequencer-wise I’m not sure what’s out there right now, there used to be Modstep, or can try Fugue machine with audiobus

DMX and visuals would be very tricky to do, but can try making a workaround with OSC and Max maybe??

PO-133: probably Koala sampler or Samplr app

The problem with phone apps is that if developer gives up or it’s taken down from app store then you’re SOL. The upside of TE hardware stuff is that it always works (unless some hardware breaks and you need ti look up replacement / repairs)

[worthless-trash]

Not op (haw haw). What is the iPad software that has the same features in 1 app?