Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by corysama 5136 days ago
Having the GPU compute position updates into a texture would indeed be orders of magnitude faster, but it would require the vertex shader to read from a texture to get the results. Unfortunately, vertex texturing is an extension that is not required in the WebGL standard and not supported on a significant percentage of machines. It's almost a shame that vertex texturing makes really fun demos really easy to make. Every time I see a VT demo, there are dozen of comments crying "Doesn't work for me. WebGL is broken!"
1 comments
ajross 5136 days ago
No need to read the texture in the vertex shader. Render to a buffer object and use that as your vertex array. But broadly yes: that's the problem with OpenGL support, and WebGL in particular is still very bleeding edge.

I'd be pretty surprised if vertex texture fetch wasn't supported though. It works on basically all hardware from the PVR SGX on up. Unified shaders are pervasive on both phones and desktops. I did find this, though, which implies that for a while that the browsers weren't properly exposing support:

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/4349389/webgl-texture-acc...

link
corysama 5136 days ago
> Render to a buffer object and use that as your vertex array.

I don't think that's an option in ES2 or WebGL. I'd love to be proven wrong!

link
ajross 5136 days ago
FBOs are absolutely part of ES2, and thus presumably an official part of WebGL. I've used them in embedded contexts, but never in a browser. And as always, this is on the bleeding edge of what the drivers are prepared for, so dragons may lurk. But at least in principle it should work.
link
corysama 5136 days ago
I've seen talk of CPU-less render-to-vertexbuffer dating back to 2004, but I've never dug into how to actually do it until now. From what I can dig out, it requires PBOs which are not available in ES2. I guess copying back and forth over the bus via gl.bufferData(ARRAY_BUFFER, gl.readPixels(...), gl.STREAM_DRAW)) is still better than doing the math in JS. I might have to try combining the glReadPixels with the mapped buffer extension that is available on the iPhone P:
link