Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ec109685 800 days ago
Hallucinations are lies. So not the same thing.
5 comments

For LLM to lie it would need to know the truth. That's an incredible level of anthropomorphization.
Hallucinations are not always lies, they are more like a transformation in the abstraction space.
That is some weapons grade spin :-)
All lies aren't useless, some can be insightful even when blatantly wrong in themselves (for instance: taken literally every scientific model is a lie). I can definitely see how an LLM hallucinating can helps fostering creativity (the same way psychedelics can), even if all they say is bullshit.
I'm using hallucination to mean "not exactly the thing", not outright lying. So maybe the "truth" is "My socks are wet." A hallucination could be "My socks are damp."
Lies require intent. I can ask a model to lie and it will provide info it knows is inaccurate, and can provide the true statement if requested.

Hallucinations are inaccuracies it doesn't realize are inaccurate.