Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rors 791 days ago
My partner is a surgeon in the UK. She's planning on leaving the profession at the end of the year. We talk a lot about what is wrong with the medical profession.

One issue is the type of person attracted to the profession. They're incredibly academically talented, not driven by money, and desire status and recognition. Surgeons are the most extreme cases of this personality type, as they're harder jobs to get and have a lot of pressure. These people are the types who get their head done, roll up their sleeves, and get on with things. They're not used to asking for help or additional resources. They're the sort of people who care for others! Medicine self-selects for martyrs.

In addition, you have so many hoops to jump through (training, specialisations, etc) with significant time investment that can be lost in moments by pissing off training directors or other senior doctors. My partner ends up working more than her contracted hours because her bosses expect her to, although they would never explicitly enforce stricter rules. If she works her contracted hours she can kiss a consultant job (UK equivalent of attending) goodbye as her bosses won't provide a reference for the role.

Because the stakes in medicine are literally life and death, meaning that it is heavily regulated. There are horror stories around the GMC, the UK regulator, and doctors are terrified of being investigated. They adopt a legalistic mentality where they only treat if they're sure that they won't get prosecuted. It's very different from aviation with its no blame culture.

Finally, another factor that is making medicine so tough is that it is a success story! People live longer, and pathologies that were once fatal can be managed with ever more complex treatments. As demographics lean to older populations, then the demand keeps increasing.