[ajcp]

I use "whelming" almost daily to denote something that I or the person I'm talking to expect to be over/underwhelming, but turns out not to be.

Them: "How'd you like that new burger joint Bad Jimmies? I heard it's amazing!"

Me: "Not bad, but I found their burgers to be...[0] whelming."

0. The pregnant pause-for-effect is very important here, since it makes even the use of "whelming" a whelming experience.