Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by paulddraper 808 days ago
I played Total Annihilation as a kid. Finding Beyond All Reason was amazing.

And spectating 8v8+ with tens of thousands of units is something else.

It's unfortunate that large scale RTS isn't a more popular genre.

Instead it's all Fortnite/CoD/WoW

4 comments

I still play Total Annihilation. I am not a "gamer" and don't play any computer games anymore, but boy do I still love Total Annihilation.

My cousin was a tester for Cavedog in the late 90s and gave us a copy before it was big. I still have some CDs!

Love to see Beyond All Reason continuing the spirit.

It feels like Starcraft 2 was the last traditional RTS; I suspect part of that is because other developers think their game wouldn't have a chance without competitive multiplayer as tight as SC2's.

That said, there's still some RTS games in the indie space / on Steam, like Homeworld: Deserts of something. But that one was ultimately disappointing overall.

The popularity of Starcraft confused me until I realized it was a really a "user interface game" rather than a strategy game. I mean, Starcraft 2 is still a strategy game, but if you were to propose changing the UI to enable more strategy, they wouldn't do that. The UI is the game, and once I understood that I understood Starcraft players better and was able to appreciate the game better.

It's hard for anyone to do a better Starcraft because it's a UI game based in technology of the time. We aren't going to get better at traditional computer screens with a fixed aspect ratio and a mouse. That is Stracraft.

Also, you mentioned Homeworld, and Homeworld 3 will be out in a few months.

That reminds me, somewhat tangentially, of working with a personal trainer in a gym and made some comment about a particular type of movement being done in a more "efficient" way and the dude was just like "that's not the point", and playing starcraft more efficiently is likewise not the point.
if you haven't seen already, check YouTube where the mods enable larger lobbies.

There are some really good casts of 40 vs 40 players or more!

Here's a recent 25 vs 25: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=btnU_IPWPmY

Oh I have. Those are wild.
I still play the CNC games every once in a while.