Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jqpabc123 806 days ago
Thanks Roku for explaining why I shouldn't buy a Roku TV or really any "smart" TV.

"Smart" refers to how it benefits the manufacturer more so than the user.

1 comments

You know Ive been looking for a dumb tv for so long - i just want the size, a bunch of HDMI/USB ports and wifi connectivity that i can stream to... Thats all. How is it that these "dumb" monitors are so much more expensive than smart tvs that dont last more than a year or 2?
BestBuy house brand (Insignia I think) are dumb and cheap but no wifi.

I use a mini PC with an air mouse to add my own "smarts" that I can control.

Hmm I suppose wifi can be augmented with some kind of connected nas. Still mess no?
I just use a small little PC (no NAS) to stream content from the internet. For local, over the air broadcasts, I use a Hauppague external USB dual tuner that has been rock solid for years.

The PC controls everything using a gyro/air mouse. The only thing the big dumb TV provides is a HDMI display. No mess, no ads, no injected content, no spying. I have full control of what I choose to see --- sports, movies, etc.. You would be hard pressed to name something I can't get.

https://www.amazon.com/Wireless-Control-Gyroscope-Learning-P...

https://www.amazon.com/Hauppauge-WinTV-DualHD-Tuner-Windows-...

https://www.dvbviewer.com/en/index.php

sceptre tvs are pretty affordable. Have been using it for a while - no issues. No wifi though, just hdmi and usb.
I'm currently in the market for a 55-inch Sceptre "dumb TV", for a family member, having seen them frequently recommended on HN.

But I can't find one anywhere! I even tried e-mailing the sales contact on their Web site, but I haven't heard back. Any pointers?

(I can't find a 55-inch Insignia, either -- that's the other "dumb" brand that gets some recommendations, including in this thread.)