Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by xfalcox 812 days ago
> Is that within the defined data processing purposes of all Discourse setups?

It's an optional plugin that can be enabled / disabled by the site admin. Those modules are all disabled by default, and each need to be enabled by the site owner.

> Edit: and apparently it also tries to flag NSFW chat messages, does Discourse have PM chats where this would flag private messages for admins to read or is it only public chats that this bot runs on?

Discourse PMs can be read by admins, see the definition here: https://meta.discourse.org/t/guidance-and-best-practices-on-...

1 comments

Of course an admin can always open up the database and read your forum PMs, that's not surprising. The very first line in the link you provided, however, is what I was worried about:

> Moderators can read PMs that have an active flag.

This system is now setting nsfw flags in an automated fashion, specifically seeking out content that the persons involved wouldn't want others to see. Clearly a forum is the wrong place for that content, but people don't always make good decisions (especially kids; I was a kid on forums too and would be very surprised if nothing ever transpired there). The receiving person can already flag anything they deem inappropriate. A system making automated decisions about messages that were intended to be private creates problems and it is not clear to me who this serves

> it is not clear to me who this serves

customers