Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sweetheart 823 days ago
Treating an animal well sometimes does not mean that the animal was treated well. It's nice that the cows you're talking about are given lots of access to pastures, but that doesn't mean that anything else can be done to the animal without it qualifying as disrespectful or unkind.

I can't think of another situation in which one could choose to kill an animal for pleasure at 10% it's lifespan, and think that this was kind or respectful. Can you?
2 comments
blendergeek 823 days ago
When a lion kills a gazelle on the savannah, is that "kind and respectful"?

No, it's just part of the "circle of life".

Humans also interact with their environment and eat non human life forms (plants, cows, etc).

If we prove that trees have consciousness, will we need to stop killing them as well? Where does it end?

link
sweetheart 823 days ago
The morality of our actions isn’t determined by what lions do.

As for the tree hypothetical, why don’t we cross that bridge when we get there.

link
toss1 823 days ago
Where it should end is with humans creating engineered (whether genetic-engineered, or using fungi, etc. is irrelevant) foods and materials such that we don't need to be farming, brutalizing, and killing animals and plants on industrial scales, deforesting vast regions to graze cattle, etc.. We are likely generations away from that, but it does seem to be the direction we're headed.
link
smogcutter 823 days ago
The irony is that argument also ends in the effective extinction of most farmed animals, or at the very least a massive die-off.
link
short_sells_poo 823 days ago
Animals receive and give very little mercy or kindness in nature. In fact, nature is capable of stunning brutality - eg newly "crowned" male lions kill off the cubs of the old male.

Humans have a capacity of reasoning about their actions, which places a certain responsibility on us to do better than nature. But where do you draw the line?

Ultimately we shouldn't eat animals at all - we should eat lab grown meat. But lab grown meat is still far away. So what do we do in the mean time? Ban all meat consumption? Is that even realistic?

link
sweetheart 823 days ago
> So what do we do in the mean time?

Those with access to all the makings for a healthy plant-based diet should stop paying for animal products. It's that simple.

link