Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by GTP 814 days ago
There was an interesting talk at one edition of CCC that boiled down to saying those techniques work only if you have the right to remain silent. Which depends on the country you're in. And I heard that in the USA, even though you have the right to remain silent, they still have the right to put you in jail if you refuse to give out your key.
1 comments
semanticist 813 days ago
You're thinking the RIP Act in the UK where the police can get an order from a judge for you to turn over a key/passphrase and you need to either prove you don't know it or face up to two years in jail (five for cases of child abuse or national security).

I'm not American but I'm pretty sure no law like that in the US would be upheld at appeal, it's pretty directly conflicting with the 5th amendment.

link
GTP 813 days ago
I heard it specifically for the USA in at least two occasions. I don't remeber the first, but the latter was in the Brett Jonson's show: in an episode, he talked about another criminal that had some encrypted material and refused to give out the key. He was put in jail until he decided to give it, and at that point IIRC he got an even longer sentence due to the proof he gave them access to. But now that I think about it, it could be that the USA had him arrested by a third country, so maybe some other state's law was at stake. But I would still not bet my safety on it. Even if you successfully appeal it, you would still risk to spend quite some time in prison.

I'm not a lawyer, but from what I remember in the USA the 5th amendment defense works only with some kinds of keys: it works with a password, but wouldn't work with a "pattern" (i.e. Android's option of drawing a pattern by connecting dots) or biometric authentication.

link
pests 813 days ago
I remember a case too. They were 100% certain a hard drive contained CSAM but could not get the password. I'm pretty sure he was jailed for contempt until it was given out. Definitely inside the USA.

This might be it, I might be misremember the finer details:

https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-36159146

link
pests 813 days ago
I remember a case too. They were 100% certain a hard drive contained CP but could not get the password. I'm pretty sure he was jailed for contempt until it was given out. Definitely inside the USA.
link
dormento 812 days ago
"prove you don't know"

It might be my lack of coffee, but how would that work? You can prove you know something, but how would you prove you don't?

link