Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by retSava 825 days ago
Not necessarily. Often rf modules are pre-certified mostly to show that the hardware implementation and radio modulation and all that works as intended. Eg no spurious emissions, transmits at the freq you ask for etc.

What gp asks for is that regulation requires either polite transmissions aka listen before talk aka clear channel assessment, ie before we send, listen for a while and back off if channel is busy. If LBT isn't used, there's a maximum allowed transmission duty cycle stated.

Zigbee typically uses LBT, Lora doesn't. Hence, a clear zigbee channel may result in a very chatty lora channel.

And another problem is the difference in bandwidth, where zb uses 250kbit/s at 2.4 GHz and a transmission may take on the order of a millisecond, Lora even on minimum spread takes hundreds of ms, on max spread a single transmission can take several seconds.

This limits the scalability of lora networks in dense physical deployments. Lora primary use case is the once-a-day-ish sensor transmission.

1 comments

LoRa is also used in latency sensitive environments, eg. Crossfire, R9 and ExpressLRS for racing drone control links. This is even with LBT enabled.