Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by quartesixte 818 days ago
A bit of a meta comment, but the character-based criticisms I find fascinating because:

1) Golden Age SciFi (Asimov, Clarke, etc) had the same “problems” 2) It’s leveled as real criticism instead of a matter of taste? I think there should be room for fiction-as-idea-vehicles as much as there is room for characters-as-core.

3BP and its sequels sit very squarely in both the latter camp as well as follows a lot of cues from Chinese fantasy epics (classic and modern). It has been a while since we have had some good High Science Fiction and the ideas were thought provoking enough.

I have a personal bone to pick with the Cult-of-the-Character but that’s something for another day…