Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pradn 818 days ago
== Spoilers for the first book ==

I tell everyone to skip the first one. The problem is that when you hear of the series, it sounds so cool. "What if humanity knew aliens were arriving in ~X hundred years?" But it takes until the end of the first book for that to premise to even arrive.

You can read a summary of the first book, and go directly to the second, which has a different set of characters on a different timeline.

All the cool stuff in the first book:

1. The alien planet is at the mercy of 2 suns, so it deals with extreme heat and cold. Predicting the trajectory of their planet (the "three-body problem" in question) is a life-or-death problem.

2. To solve this, the aliens set up computers using a lot of alien-people, each acting as a logic gate - each person passes information to the next.

3. A pro-alien group uses lasers to cut up ships at the Panama canal or whatever.

Pretty much the rest of the book is quite boring. The pro-alien society that meets in a video game is laughable.

The second book has a propulsive cadence that's super fun to read, and the third has a series of amazing conceptually-creative micro-worlds - so captivating!

4 comments

Why are you spoiling the book like this?
Sorry added a spoiler alert.
Thank you, I read the first book but didn't come away with even half of that. I don't know why, but I couldn't follow the book at all.
-- SPOILER ALERT (at parent comment, not mine) --

The first book is more akin to universal literature than strictly sci-fi. It literally opens with scenes from the Cultural Revolution. It's a slow burn that gradually touches on science subjects to eventually throw all the fiction into the reader's face. It has one of the best endings you'll find in sci-fi.

It's a great book especially for begginers of the genre.

> 3. A pro-alien group uses lasers to cut up ships at the Panama canal or whatever.

So much for an accurate summary.

It's not even close to all the cool stuff from the first book. Hopefully someone who has scrolled this far has seen spoiler warnings, but the explanation of the Sophons is one of the more stunning and imaginative ideas in the book, and foundational to its premise.