Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JonAtkinson 831 days ago
These assertions are just not true. I'm working right now on a document with coworkers, concurrently, via a Sharepoint server. Change tracking is enabled and can even be enabled by default by the Sharepoint admin.

I share a lot of your sentiment about open formats in previous comments, but this is classic FUD and demonstrably wrong.
1 comments
brnt 831 days ago
Then our Sharepoint server must have disabled sth. I regularly get a message on save that the document has changed meanwhile, with the option to overwrite those changes or discard my own...

No change tracking is visible to me, other than a timestamp and name of last edited.

FUD is isn't. Please don't use buzzword gratuitously, I know _a lot_ more about the deployment here than you. Also, you didn't counter the statement that it doesn't do concurrent editing (like Google Docs, OnlyOffice), which in 2024 is a major gap imho.

link
JonAtkinson 831 days ago
Your original comment was speaking in general terms, about all Sharepoint services. Not your specific deployment. Details matter or your argument falls down.

As for concurrency, read my comment again, I use the specific word.

link
brnt 831 days ago
If you see that I talk about a certain config of Sharepoint, it's much faster to point that out than being argumentative.

What did you do to have concurrent editing (or what did you not do), and how does it integrate the various diffs?

link