Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Zambyte 835 days ago
> If you don't want to be under the thumb of an operating system, don't use it.

How do you do that without replacing the hardware?

> You want copyleft worth a damn?

I don't. I want a world without copyright, and I recognize that means taking copyleft with it.

> If you want to cancel all intellectual property rights with respect to software

My desire is more radical: I wish for a world without intellectual propery. Yes, that includes patents, trademarks, and creative copyright. Of course they all have different implications, but I really believe the world with be a better place without all of them. They each mainly serve to better their "owners" (almost exclusively not the creators) rather than better humanity.

1 comments

> How do you do that without replacing the hardware?

As I said earlier—

If you want to make an argument for requiring Apple (et al) to provide straightforward mechanisms for rejecting the supplied software and installing alternative operating systems (e.g. Asahi Linux) then I'll support it to the ends of the earth. I'd be your most vocal supporter. I'd be delighted if this was a legal requirement of all computer hardware, from mainframes to microwaves.

> I wish for a world without intellectual propery.

Cool, but appreciate that this places you in an extreme minority position, and one which destroys your own argument. Without copyright, you don't get to assert any implied rights which normally come from "buying" software. Without copyright, you received nothing of value from Apple except the hardware. If Apple don't own the software that's on YOUR device, they cannot be held responsible for what it does.