Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Krasnol 838 days ago
They have usernames now.

Using it with a dedicated username for whatsapp contacts could be a way.

1 comments

Signal would have to change how they work for that, at present it shares your profile name after you've initiated a chat using the "username" - very confusing choice of wording.
What do you mean? You can set a nickname but they'll send your phone number to everyone you chat with?

What's the point of nicknames then?

https://signal.org/blog/phone-number-privacy-usernames/

> Usernames simply allow you to initiate a connection on Signal without sharing your phone number

> Starting soon, your phone number will no longer be visible to people you chat with on Signal, unless they have it in their phone’s contacts. You will also be able to configure a new privacy setting to limit who can find you by your phone number on Signal. And, you’ll now be able to create an optional username that you can share with the people you want to connect with on Signal.

> unless they have it in their phone’s contacts

Lol. Why should they be allowed to associate my phone with my signal handle even then. If i want them to know I'll tell them.

> a new privacy setting to limit who can find you by your phone number on Signal

Double lol. Limit is not disable.

How about an option to "do not give my phone number to anyone, no matter what reason to pass it around you make up this week"?

And the obvious next step: do not get my phone number period. But that has been discussed before.

As far as I can tell, "limit" will soon mean "disable". They just can't flip that switch yet given that legacy clients will not know what to do about "numberless contacts".

> do not get my phone number period

I'd also like that, but they apparently use phone numbers as a primary key for account recovery and identification (e.g. on a new device without the old one present), so that's probably very hard to change architecturally.

There are some interesting concepts of "identityless messengers", but this is inherently hard to do on mobile – at least the platform operator will always know which identities are clustered together on a given device if you want efficient push notification delivery over APNs/FCM.

> There are some interesting concepts of "identityless messengers"

Like... icq... yahoo messenger... old skype... ?

And even some modern mobile chat apps i think.

Currently everyone who chats with me cannot see my phone number — even people who have my phone number saved in their phone (I was surprised as I thought it would still show this if they had it saved). There is a setting to entirely hide your phone number from everyone.