|
|
|
|
|
|
by Chris_Newton
843 days ago
|
|
|
But it's orders of magnitude too slow and memory-inefficient for performance-sensitive graph computations—if you have even moderately sized graphs and graph algorithms are a bottleneck, you'll need to use something else, and probably something domain-specific. This seems a little pessimistic to me. There are plenty of application domains that can be conveniently represented using graphs where you might have thousands of nodes and edges — which is what I’d characterise as “moderately sized” — and your needs might only extend to relatively simple and efficient graph algorithms. FGL is excellent in this kind of scenario. If you do need the kind of algorithms that explode in complexity then even a representation a couple of orders of magnitude more efficient won’t help you much either. Big-O is the thing that is going to spoil your day in this story, not the constant factor. Some problems simply don’t have convenient fast solutions and ideally with those you find a way to change the representation so the original problem doesn’t arise in the first place. It’s true that there’s also a zone where you have significantly larger graphs but still only need computationally tractable algorithms, and in that case the overheads of a library like FGL become a factor in what is viable. I also don’t disagree with you (and Hillel in the original piece) that it would be difficult to define comprehensive graph functionality to include in a standard library when there are so many different trade-offs involved. A good — and not entirely unconnected — analogy might be calculating with matrices. It’s convenient to have support for simple but widely useful cases like 3x3 and 4x4 built into your language or standard library. However, once you’re solving systems with hundreds or thousands of rows, you probably want more specialised tools like BLAS/LAPACK, and the structure of your matrix and how you can decompose it start to matter a lot more. |
|
|
The GraphBLAS and LAGraph are sparse matrix optimized libraries for this exact purpose:
https://github.com/DrTimothyAldenDavis/GraphBLAS
https://github.com/GraphBLAS/LAGraph/