Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dividefuel 836 days ago
My feeling is it became politicized because the left saw it as a chance to expose Trump, and the right downplayed it to avoid impacts on Trump's reputation. Like because one side took one stance, the other side inherently had to take a different stance.

The right started out as "Covid is bad, but so is crashing the economy to prevent it", which turned into "Covid isn't that bad, wearing a mask is excessive", which became "The vaccine is more harmful than the disease". The left went from "Causing people to die is worse than any economy hit" -> "You should do everything possible to prevent it" -> "You should wear a mask at all times in public".

I often feel the left would have taken reversed stances if the right had taken the pandemic seriously. If Trump had advocated shutting things down and pushed strongly for vaccines/masks, it seems pretty likely the left would have called this an authoritarian overreach and/or highly questioned the safety of the vaccines.

In short, I think our culture is so highly polarized that as soon as something becomes a major topic, people immediately divide into separate 'sides' on it.

EDIT: follow-up question -- was the pandemic as polarizing in other countries besides the US?

3 comments

Doesn't seem to have been as durably polarizing elsewhere, as far as I can tell.

EG: even European countries that were more draconian earlier in the pandemic returned to relative normalcy, with less fear/debate around school reopenings, mandatory testing, mandatory masking, etc, sooner than the US.

In the US, sticky "showy extreme COVID vigilance is my essential identity as a good citizen" or "showy nonchalance is my essential identity as a free person" partisanship lingers.

>it seems pretty likely the left would have called this an authoritarian overreach and/or highly questioned the safety of the vaccines.

Biden, Harris, and Pelosi all said in September 2020 that they won't trust any Trump vaccine. <https://www.newsweek.com/anti-vaccine-covid-trust-skepticism...>

I mean, given what he said about trying bleach in people, I think I'd be a bit skeptical about his vaccines as well.
Both parties of capital have handled this pandemic terribly:

https://www.thegauntlet.news/p/how-the-press-manufactured-co...