Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by evandale 847 days ago
How is it possible for a user of AWS to keep the account ID secret if Amazon doesn't even consider it secret? If Amazon leaked your account ID they could point to their docs and say the account ID was never meant to be a secret, sensitive, or confidential.
1 comments
kube-system 847 days ago
You can walk over to the user's desk and ask them not to share it. Whether or not Amazon leaks it is unrelated to my employees' ability to follow instructions.

There is a lot of data that exists in a space somewhere between "100% secret" and "100% public". This is one of those situations, for many organizations.

link
abadpoli 847 days ago
You’re wasting your employees time by asking them to keep it secret, when you gain absolutely no benefit from keeping it secret (and in fact are introducing an easy failure point by pretending it’s secret) and you have no guarantees that others are keeping it secret.

> This is one of those situations, for many organizations.

And those organizations are wrong.

link
kube-system 847 days ago
Many organizations just have a blanket policy that you shouldn't be exposing data about an organization's infrastructure unless you need to do it. This is a good policy.

> by pretending it’s secret

No, nobody needs to pretend it is secret. You're missing my above point. There is not a dichotomy between secret and public. It is possible for something to be neither secret nor public.

link